Reign of the Dowager Empress Cixi 慈禧太后

"Empress Dowager Cixi and Four Imperial Physicians" by Huang Zhongyang. Special 
attention should be paid to the expressions of the Physicians as they try to diagnose
the sleeping empress. The look of conspiratorial secrecy in the eyes of the doctors
while the imperial authority sleeps without a clue signifies much.

The latter portion of Qing dynasty's history witnessed many challenges both from within and outside the realm. After suffering repeated defeats at the hands of the British and the French in what was known as the Opium Wars, ethnic tensions within China reached a boiling point. No less than half a dozen of massive rebellions all exploded throughout the various pockets of the empire. At the height of the chaotic unrest China saw tens of millions of Han, Hui, and many other groups openly challenging the supremacy of the Manchu court. Ultimately, the Qing government would triumph and ruthlessly crush the rebellions and prop up its hegemony for almost another half a century more. It was in this environment that the Empress Dowager Cixi came into power. 

THE CURTAIN REIGN: POWER GRAB


She rose to power immediately in the aftermath of Qing's defeat in the 2nd Opium War against the Anglo-French forces. The Qing imperial army had been smashed and the British forces under Lord Elgin looted the Qing Old Summer Palace and burned it to the ground. Beijing was lost and the imperial court took flight. In the ensuing chaos, the 30 year old Xianfeng Emperor died on during his long escape with the royal court. In his will, he named "Eight Regent Ministers" to govern the realm as regent and guide his young five year old son- the Tongzhi emperor until he matures. 


However, Cixi, the mother of Tongzhi, took the initiative and raced back to the imperial capital and degreed that the Eight Regents be immediately executed. From there, imperial power of the dynasty rested in her hands. 


Though she regarded herself as a staunch conservative who championed the supremacy of the Manchus and a defender against foreign influences. In truth, she was ignorant of the threat posed by the western empires and the great military and scientific powers the westerners possessed. During her tenure, the Qing continued to suffer a string of humiliating defeats at the hands of foreign powers while China dangerously lagged behind the rest of the maritime empires. 


During Cixi's rule the citizenry and even the court continued their addiction to opium in great numbers and the imperial military power was slowly absorbed by the regional governors. Corruption was rampant, and the empire's future was deeply uncertain as foreign powers encroached ever closer. 

"Situation in the Far East" by the Chinese revolutionary Tse Tsan Tai, which depicts the
British bulldog, the French frog, the American Eagle, the Russian bear and 
the Japanese sun disk all positioning themselves to take more out of China. Though
initially China only warred against the British, and then the French, in the decades
that followed many groups of foreigners, would arrive and stake their claims 
to carve out their areas of influences in China.


A CHANGING WORLD

Wanguo laichao tu 万国来朝图 (1760) or the "Illustration of the Myriad Tributary Nations coming to Court" Painted during the height of Qing's power during the long reign of the Qianlong Emperor. Most of the dignitaries are positioned at the lower right corner. Click for details.

Detail of the Wanguo laichao tu 万国来朝图 (1760) or the "Illustration of the Myriad Tributary Nations coming to Court" Painted during the height of Qing's power during the long reign of the Qianlong Emperor,  showing tributary representatives from predominantly European states such as England, France, Holland and the "Great Western Ocean," also Asian states such as Vietnam, Japan, the Ryukyu Islands (Kingdom of Okinawa) and the Philippines.



Age of Empires: soldiers of the Eight Nations Alliance who crushed the Boxers in Beijing. The Qing awoke to a world where they are dwarfed by much bigger and much more advanced empires that had already portioned the world among themselves. However, perhaps the most ironic of all, is that the woman who ruled China was unaware of the power posed by these foreigners. During Cixi's rule China lost to the French in Vietnam, lost Taiwan and Korea to Japan, and lost the control of the imperial homelands in Manchuria to encroaching Russian soldiers. Qingdao (Tsingtao) was lost to the Germans, and the Liaodong Peninsula to the Japanese, then the Russians. Meanwhile many ironclad foreign ships sailed in China's waterways. Within half a century, the Qing had went from being the leading power of East Asia, at the head of a dozen tributary kingdoms to being drawn and quartered by strangers from the other side of the globe. Such was the times.


WRONG EMPRESS, WRONG TIME 

Although the Qing was twice disastrously defeated at the hands of the westerners, in the 50 years that followed, there were many opportunities for the dynasty to shrug off the initial setback, modernize, and then rebound to a state of security. After all, the first Opium War happened in the early 1840s- nearly 10 years before America forced an unprepared Japan to modernize, and the 2nd happened around the same decade as Matthew Perry's opening of Japan and Japan's Boshin War. 

Cixi began as only one of the concubines of the young Xianfeng Emperor, and her life 
would have read like the tales of an East Asian Cleopatra if not for her total inability to 
read the signs of her times. She was completely unaware the power possessed by
the westerners and during her reign China was repeatedly defeated at the hands of 
foreign powers. 


However, it was here that Cixi showed her hand. Cixi would prove herself to be one of the staunchest opponents toward modernization and westernization within China. After the initial defeat at the hands of the westerners, more far-sighted ministers like Li Hongzhang attempted to modernize China by cooperating with the French and the British to build a modern army and navy. 


But Cixi staunchly opposed many of the modernization efforts that was championed from within. Because Cixi came from the ranks of the Manchu elites who were never more than a tiny percentage of the realm (as an ethnicity,) the notions of Republicanism and democracy- hence majority rule, and a modernized army with modern weaponry at the hands of the powerful military governors was very much a threat in her eyes. This: when coupled with the rising sentiment of nationalism was something she was utterly unprepared to concede to. Already, the Qing had proven that they were willing to ruthlessly crush any attempt for separatist rebels in the previous decades, in her eyes, all of these flood of "modern" western ideas only agitated for more of that.

3D digital illustration by the talented Teish Wu: The Tongzhi Emperor became emperor at the age of five upon the death of his father, the Xianfeng Emperor. His father's choice of regents for the young boy were executed by his mother, the Empress Dowager Cixi, who ruled through the boy with her ally the Empress Dowager Ci'an, and the boy's sixth uncle Prince Gong. 

\Qing Minister Li Hongzhang was a controversial figure in China because much 
of his career is overshadowed and deeply pegged with that of his patron (matron)
The Dowager Empress Cixi. Li proved his usefulness as a politician when he aided
in crushing the Taiping Rebellion and supported the rise of the Cixi Empress. However
Li was also deeply aware the vulnerability of the Qing when compared to western powers.
Time and time again Li tried to modernize China upon the western model but was
overruled by empress. Li also had the misfortune of speaking to westerners as
China's ambassador after most of Qing's disastrous defeats. For his failures, 
his toadying to Cixi's misrule, and for being the man who "gave" China
away piecemeal, Li was reviled. 


She also regarded many western institutions such as universities and western scientific developments with deep suspicion as well, not only because they contradicted the traditional orthodox Confucian way of Chinese teaching but also the traditional obedient view towards authority in China. She was remembered to have forbid the construction of railroads because they were too loud and would "disturb the emperors' tombs." 

Because Chinese court protocol forbids women from ruling directly in the imperial halls. Cixi- like many powerful female regents thus enthroned herself behind the emperor seperated by a veil. It was called Chui Lian Ting Zheng 垂帘听政: or "Reign Behind the Curtains" lit. "Listening to the Policies Through the Curtains." 

Officially Cixi was only supposed to act as the regent of the empire
while her son- the future Tongzhi Emperor ascended the throne in his majority
However he grew up to be a dissolute and stubborn young man. He clashed 
often with the ministers and spent most of his time as an idle youth. His whole
reign was overshadowed by his mother, the Empress Dowager Cixi, and when he
died childless at the tender age of 19, power was returned to his mother, who 
named his 3 year old cousin as the future Guangxu Emperor.


In the 1880s the French would officially annex Vietnam- then a tributary ally of China, and dealt many defeats to the combined Chinese- Vietnamese forces. Despite the initial modernizing efforts, Qing's Nanyang (South Sea) Fleet suffered heavy losses against the French. Within a decade, the Qing would suffer another series of humiliating defeats, this time, not only at the hands of a western power but at the hands of one of its own former Asian tributary states. 



ENEMY OF REFORM 



Between 1884–95, during the reign of the newly enthroned Guangxu Emperor (r. 1875–1908), Empress Dowager Cixi ordered 22 million silver taels, originally designated for upgrading the Qing navy (the Beiyang Fleet), to be used for reconstructing and enlarging the Summer Palace to celebrate her 60th birthday.

In 1894, Qing China was resoundingly defeated by the Japanese, in the First Sino- Japanese war. The entire Beiyang Fleet- which had been one of the most powerful in East Asia was completely destroyed and as a result of the war, Qing lost control of Taiwan and the strategically critical Liaodong Peninsula to Japan. For many in the Qing court, the fact that a former backwater tributary vassal was able to so resoundingly defeat the Qing with a fully westernized army was a great and humiliating wake up call. But not for the empress.


When Cixi's nephew, Guangxu emperor tried to initiate a series of westernizing reforms called the Hundred Day's Reform in an attempt to copy Japan. The reforms sought to nationalize the Qing state and create a modern- nationalized education system with a modern industry and military, however, Cixi re-entered into politics and dethroned him through a coup and had many of the reformers executed. The Guangxu emperor himself was forced into retirement and put under house unrest. 


Culturally she viewed the encroachment of Christianity and modern factory with deep suspicion. But in this regard, she might not be too incorrect in her judgement. After all, the disastrous Taiping Rebellion, which erupted across the realm and claimed the lives of some 20+ million people while she was young was started by a Chinese religious rebel who thought he was the "brother of Jesus Christ," and that in time, the interest- oriented merchants, might form their own power blocs and rebel against the dynasty.


REACTIONARY NATIVIST

Her suspicions and xenophobia were allayed in 1899 when a deeply disgruntled secret religious society called Yihetuan 义和团 roughly translated as "Righteous and Harmonious Fist society", or "Boxers" as they were known in the west began to attack and slaughter westerners and Chinese christian converts en mass. When the rebels revealed their motive was to totally root out the foreigners and "Revive the Qing and destroy the foreigners," Cixi threw her weight, and that of the Qing military behind the rebels against the foreigners.

In this French satirist cartoon, Britain, Germany, Russia, France, and Japan are 
carving China while a helpless Qing dynasty Mandarin looks on


However her decision- like many of the decision of her life, were poorly calculated for the times. Despite some victories and trapping the foreign legation in a siege at Beijing, the rebels and the Qing army were swept aside when the Eight Nations Alliance breached into Beijing.

For those who are aware of literary ironies and sees symmetries in human history, upon the closing of the Eight Nations Alliance army into Beijing, Cixi would- for the second time in her life escape from the capital city in humiliation. Except this time she was not a virtually unknown concubine but had in fact steered the Qing dynsty directly under her rule. Under a disguise, she fled from the city and would disappear along with her court into staunchly loyalist regions of western China, from where the westerners would have no way to pry her out.


Despite many miscalculations, Cixi was right in this maneuver. As she calculated that the covetous and mutually suspicious members of the Alliance would quickly turn on themselves after they had ransacked Beijing and freed up those who were trapped in the legation. After months of looting and violence around Beijing, the Alliance became directionless, and it was during this time Cixi offered sent Li Hongzhang for peace talks with the Alliance and brokered a peace.


Like all previous times, China would pay heavy reparations and concessions, but seeing no way that any of these nations would truly occupy China (nor does any of them wish any of their nearby rivals to gain a bigger slice of China than they would have) Cixi would be allowed to returned to power as the head of the Qing dynasty. The condition for her return included executing all of the Boxers who were responsible. Cixi agreed to this, and ultimately thousands of supposed Boxers were rounded up and beheaded in mass.



A saying at the time goes: "The peasants fear the government, the government fears the foreigner, and the foreigners fear the peasants" describes the relationship between the western powers and China as a whole at the time. Like the Ottoman Empire, the westerners saw a profitable opportunity to extract beneficial deals from a weak yet very rich central power that could be forced to pay for such reparations. However they also feared having all of the peasants collectively and dreadfully provoked to action in unison, so they resort to keep the weak government as it was to oppress the peasants and keep them in line. More than anything, they needed a tax collector to reap the tributes in a timely manner, and thus the Dowager Empress returned. It should also be noted that the Boxer Rebellion would plant the seed for the Russo Japanese War.

THE LAST ACT


Ironically, the last role Cixi would play was one that she very much did not expect: that of a begrudging reformer. Once back in the palace, Cixi implemented sweeping political reforms. High officials were dispatched to Japan and Europe to gather facts and draw up plans for sweeping administrative reforms in law, education, government structure, and social policy, many of which were modeled on the reforms of the Meiji Restoration. The abolition of the almost millennium old examination system in 1905 was only the most visible of these sweeping reforms.


It was during this time that some of China's first universities and industries began to take off. During this time, some of China's first railroad construction began in earnest. Ironically, Cixi sponsored the implementation of the New Policies, a reform program more radical than the one proposed by the reformers she had beheaded in 1898.


She also embarked on an intense personalized diplomatic campaign toward the westerners in which she had many photographs of her taken to be distributed, as both a stately sovereign, a charming matron who posed in operatic poses, and at times, a Buddhist deity. In combination, these images did their job to humanized her somewhat in the western world's eyes.

However, these measures would come too late to take much effect for her dynasty as well as China as a whole. Cixi died in 1908, only a day after she appointed the whole of the Chinese state in the hands of the 3 year old boy Emperor Puyi, also a day after her imprisoned nephew, the house-arrested Guangxu Emperor mysteriously died. The dynasty would die soon after her, for the power was already completely in the hands of the powerful men in the realm, all they had to do was to pursue their own selfish dreams in their respective domains.


VANITÉ, VANITÉ

Even before her death, Cixi had megalomaniacal dreams of cementing her posthumous status compared to her predecessors. Though she had only been a concubine and was supposed to be interred alongside her husband the Xianfeng Emperor. Cixi was dissatisfied with such a fate and took tens of million taels of silver out of the imperial treasury for the building of a massive mausoleum specifically dedicated to her. The size and scope was much larger that that of her husbands and many previous emperors. But even that was not enough to please her, in 1895, only one year after China's humiliating defeat at the hands of the Japanese in the First Sino- Japanese War, and contemporaneous to when she spent critical amount of the treasury's money on the construction of her pleasure gardens in the new Summer Palace. Cixi, unsatisfied with her already mammoth tomb, ordered its complete destruction and reconstruction in 1895- this time, to be outfitted with great temples, gold-leafed halls, gates and gardens.


For her funeral Cixi ordered one of the most expensive ceremonies. Equivalents of billions of dollars of treasury were emptied for a massive painted funeral barge which was as large as apartment blocks, decorated with effigies and painted temples to be ceremonials set ablaze for her soul. Such was what the nation spent on one who had risen as a concubine, and whose long reign was dreadfully unaware of China's vulnerabilities. Her death was the first of many awkward footings that China woke to find itself in at the beginning of the 20th century. A century of suffering would follow.

The funerary barge, which was 72 metres long and seven metres wide, was made of high-quality wood and covered in expensive silk fabric. The boat was also filled with numerous paper effigies of towers, chambers, pavilions, and dozens of life-size servants dressed in clothes. It was set on fire near the East gate of the Forbidden City, in a ceremony that was believed to grant Cixi a better afterlife. As for her remains, Cixi was buried with with jewellery and other luxury items worth about 1.2 million taels of silver, the equivalent of billions of dollars from the treasury.


THE CURTAINS CLOSES



Ultimately Cixi presided over the terminal stages of the empire while it was diluted from within and carved up from the outside. It is little surprising that only 3 years after Cixi died in 1908 the Qing was completely overthrown by Republican rebels.


To Cixi's credit, she was right in her suspicions, when the Republicans finally toppled the dynasty in 1912, many rebels came from the more "westernized" industrialists from southern China. And one of the key rebels: Sun Yat sen, who would become the president of the new Republic of China was heavily supported his wife's family, themselves being rich Chinese Methodist bankers in Hawaii.





So hi all 😄! I want you to know that your support has really meant a lot to me. Last year I was able to write 38 articles with your support, and this year I have wrote over 60 articles before the final quarters of 2018. I really plan to spend more time doing this, and find more opportunities to sit down and get the things I have been reading to you guys on a more consistent basis 🧐. Same goes for doing more Youtube videos, artworks and doing more commissioned concept art for you if you care to book it. 

→ ☯ [PLEASE SUPPORT ME @ PATREON] ☯ ←

😏 It would be a huge solid for me on a personal level as well since I am between jobs and have to balance churning out articles, buying new books for research, family, and doing new artworks. If you like my works and like to see more of it. Please think of supporting me on Patreon or book an artwork from me- as this great gesture would mean the world to me, because you are already the world to me at this moment. Thank you 🤗.

Thank you to my Patrons who has contributed $10 and above: 
You helped make this happen!
➢ ☯ José Luis Fernández-Blanco
➢ ☯ Vincent Ho (FerrumFlos1st)
➢ ☯ BurenErdene Altankhuyag
➢ ☯ Stephen D Rynerson
➢ ☯ Steven Chan
➢ ☯ Michael Lam


Comments

Dmitry said…
I wonder if there could be a worst ruler. At the same time her policy was terribly destructive and incompetent, but at the same time she showed extreme skill in keeping herself in power, continuing the decline uninterrupted.
What shocks me the most about this period of Chinese history is its absolute military weakness.
In the Imjin war Ming China, despite massive corruption and military neglect, presented itself as a power, with a rather modern military, willing to adapt tactically and technologically, while behind the west, it seems to have been able to give a serious fight to any western army of the time. By 1840 its power was literally nonexistent and would continue to remain this way till 1937, when it finally showed some ability to actually fight (no matter how badly). It isn't just that the Qing lost wars, Ottomans also lost wars to Russia, but only after forcing Russia to commit a good part of its troops and sacrificing over 100 000 of its soldiers. The Qing empires entire army could have been beaten by a regiment. One western regiment could have landed at Tianjin, marched to the capital and take the forbidden city smashing any resistance aside. Equipment wasnt even the main point. During the Sino-Japanese war and the boxer rebellion, many Qing units were well equipped with western arms, but their soldiers couldn't hit the enemy and often fired while out of range. They would then flee at first salvo. During the Boxer rebellion, the Russian general Rennenkampf took a city with a 50 000 strong garrison with a cavalry brigade, the amount of modern arms and artillery he found there surpassed that of an entire Russian army corps. These men were not soldiers at all, they were a ballast, good only for killing peasants. I'm sure, that had they faced the Ming army in the Imjin war, or the Qing conquest army, they would have been swept away, no matter their equipment.
By the first Opium war, the Qing army was armed worst then the Ming army 230 years earlier. I have no idea how it became so bad.
I do wonder though if the Manchu elite did face a problem of legitimacy. After Dorgon forced the pigtail on the Chinese, all following Qing rulers were very much the opposite, trying carefully to be as Confucian as possible, as if they were assured, that the Han population would not forgive them deviations as much as they might do so to the Ming or other Han rulers. Maybe the Qing felt a lack of legitimacy and hence were afraid of change?
Also didn't the Qing de facto lose control over the south, after the Taiping rebellion? Since the rebellion was mostly suppressed by local forces, local Han elites took over afterwards? How much of an empire was China at Cixis death? What did she even think? Her state was falling apart at her exes and she just watched, suppressing any attempt to counter all of it. Did she care about the empire? Or only about keeping herself in power for a bit longer? She didn't even seemed to have cared for the Manchu as a people, since she gave away Manchuria rather quickly.
Dmitry said…
"Liaodong Penninsula was lost to the Germans."

I tought the Russians leased it? And then lost it to Japan 1905.

Germany got Kiautschou and concessions in Shandong I think?
Der said…
A disgraceful period in Chinese history only now is China escaping slowly from.

The Manchu were degenerate rulers and should have been overthrown earlier. They were not up to the task of a modern Warring States Period against the European powers.
Dmitry said…
http://eh.net/eha/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/Broadberry.pdf page 36 shows well how much Chinas wealth declined under the Qing (yes the population did grow from 160-200 at 1600 to 400 million at 1800, but Tokugawa Japan had a similar growth, but still maneged to grow its per capita GDP), one of the main reasons, why Japan modernized and China didnt, was because Japan had a highly legitimate regime in its Imperial house, which could demand changes from the population, while China had a foreign regime, that constantly feared for its power and had to keep Chinese traditions intact, since it felt it lacked legitemacy.
Der said…
@Dmitry,

I agree with your assessment of the Manchu Qing as being foreign to China. They are to China what the Etrusans are to the early Romans, or the Normans to the English, or Bolsheviks to Russia.
Dragon's Armory said…
@Dmitry

You are so right, Port Arthur was controlled by the Japanese and Russians and precipitated the Russo Japanese War. I was going to say Qingdao or Tsingtao but instead thought of Dalian.

I will change that immediately. Thanks for letting me know :)
Dragon's Armory said…
@Dmitry and @Der
Thank you for your comments and I pretty much agree with the points you have made. I have to say, that a lot of native people from within China were quite surprised to find that the Qing were very well equipped when they saw the pictures of their weapons, the qualities they purchased, and the navy they had. Looking at the specific ships of the Beiyang and Nanyang Fleet they were rather formidable and some times, in the case of the several ironclads the Qing purchased, were actually superior to that Japan had at the time. There simply is no excuse that China should be defeated that badly and that continuously within the span of some 60 years, all of which she presided with a murderous iron fist against anything and everything that remotely suggested westernization.

Sure, China would have to suffer several initial defeats as a wake up call compared to the power differentials between it and the rest of the European empires. But 60 years continuously, while being surpassed by a former tributary vassal and being kicked around by strangers from across the globe? Such a giant wake up call~ while the Empress: as the painting depicted metaphorically slept while the ministers almost winked at the watcher of the painting with a conspiratorial wink.
Dmitry said…
If Im not mistaken, the Qing army didnt even really supress the Taiping rebellion?
Local units, created by local elites did that. The Qing army was probably only a danger to unarmed civilians back then....
Dragon's Armory said…
It was a disgrace in many areas, yes. But it should be pointed out that same decade the Qing were fighting in at least four massive rebellions across all of the empire, the east was dominated by the Taiping rebels, the south west was dominated by the Hui and Han rebels in Yunnan near Dali, in the northwest there was a massive rebellion there as well. Although the Qing spent most of the latter part of the 19th century getting smashed against more powerful western empires. One should see that the Qing- and the local governors destroyed all of the domestic rebellions and slaughter rebels by the hundreds of thousands. The Taiping rebellion also caused a famine which killed off tens of millions.

One of the reasons a lot of western powers did not all "go in" even after they breached into Beijing is because the specter of what a massively rebellious China looked like. The western armies might win decisive pitched battles but none of them had a staging ground for both garrison and projection of their powers, especially trying to act as a peace keeping force while surrounded by a deeply hostile populace. By then they will simply loose by attrition. The Spanish in the Philippines and Cuba had almost an endless series of rebellions that they were never able to put down and most nations simply didn't want that. ^Which is why they rather have someone like Cixi to act as their tax collector while letting her repress many regions in her domains.

As the saying goes, "the foreigners fear the peasants, the peasants fear the government, the governor fear the foreigners."
Dmitry said…
Japan experienced that very much in WW2, although the KMT army was ofcourse infinitly better then the late Qing army.

Wasnt the Taiping rebellion not mostly supressed, by regionaly raised units? Led by local Han gentry and trained in a western way?

I think the total weakness of the Qing military did allready show itself, during the white lotus rebellion in the late 18th century?

Back then Qianlong did complain, that his Green standart troops couldnt even load their muskets.
Dragon's Armory said…
The KMT at least tried to herald the identity of a Chinese state's Chinese troops defending their own nation. A good deal of respect must be give to them because they were only recently formed, since only a decade before China was filled with Beiyang Warlords. That is why Japan was surprised by both Shanghai and Changsha, compared to what they expected, even compared to the western nations in the European theater they did more than expected.

As for your 2nd question: That's why I mentioned that the local military governors had their power drastically increased during this period. It's more useful to be ad Hoc and have many responders police the local regions. A lot of governors became very powerful during this period, and the Hui generals controlled much of western China. But as a consequence of this, after the Qing was toppled the regional warlords were able to go against each other because by that point power has been entrenched on a local level.

Qianlong had problems, yes, but he aggressively deployed his soldiers on many campaigns and at times personally trained troops specifically dedicated for a task, including special wall- scaling troops called Jianruiying he personally raised to scale the endless enemy tower fortresses in the Jinchuan region. Where he had problems in his initial invasion due to failure to assault the tower forts, after forming this unit and drilling them endlessly, in his later assault his Jianruiying did remarkably well and took many fort towers.
Dmitry said…
Thank you for the answer,

I do agree, that the KMT did very much with very little. Their situation was a terrible one and they did at least manege to create a Chinese army, that could fight back and inflict serious casualties. In the economy too, despite being at war against warlords and communists, they did manege a massive growth in the areas they controlled.

When did the Qing army reach the terrible state it was in at the first Opium war?
Dragon's Armory said…
I have to attribute it to the tail end of Qianlong's long reign, his close relationship with the corrupt minister He Shen eventually allowed He to amass a huge amount of money in private. When Qianlong died his son JiaQing went after He Shen and had his estates confiscated, it was discovered that there contained enough money to equal the total GPD of the Qing court for several years. Despite the 19th century emperor's attempts to try to combat corruption the corruption would continue during this period.

Another factor is that a lot of the leadership of the Qing army effectively became hereditary and in the context where there was not many wars the institutional experiences simply degraded while the court focused its attention elsewhere. I distinctively remember that an account by some British envoys to the Qing remarked that they were not impressed with the local military officers who spent of their time simply coasting on the reputation of their martial ancestors but did not spent much time drilling and training, and sense the common man and its leadership never spend much time *realizing how huge the western powers have became, how their army and society fared (due to China's isolation) they never took the west seriously, huge mistake.

The final bitter truth is that the Qing simply have to have their teeth smashed in during an engagement with a western empire to wake up. There is simply no way of getting around that. By the late 19th century the Qing were still living as overlords over many tributary states, secure in imagining they were the center of the world and being acknowledged by their vassals as such while the world was almost entirely made "western." Due to the massive power differentials of the empires, any engagement with a nearby western power will probably result in a bitter defeat, it's not if but when and who. But that's still okay though, it will not be a unique fate, just because the initial struggle was lopsided did not preclude that the native people from quickly waking up and changing their stations. But sadly in this regard the Qing leadership simply wished to keep their eyes closed and freeze the world as the one they were born in.. A lot of very short sighted and obsolete decisions in the end.

I don't know if you know this but throughout the 20th century there is a very keen sense of vulnerability in the minds of many Chinese people, even the most conservative ones did not advocate completely preserving society because most realize the danger of being blind while lagging behind, without parity it simply means the damage dealt back will be lopsided.
Rayray said…
To be fair, the Sino-French war was a close one. The naval debacle in Fuzhou where the entire Fujian fleet was sunk with minimal French losses, that was needless to say pathetic. But on land the Black Flag / Qing forces were a lot more scrappy and actually inflicted defeats to the French, though they also lost some as well. But if they have pressed on they might've pulled their first win against the West since the French public at the time was rattled by the losses to the point of causing a cabinet change. But overall the China's record against foreign powers during this period was very bad. Especially considering that Zulu, Ethiopian, Maori forces with even less equipment/resources manage to score clear victories over Western forces..there really is no excuse
T. G. said…
This comment has been removed by the author.

Popular Posts